Construction’s position in NZ’s poor productivity outcomes

New Zealand’s persistently weak productivity performance has become one of the defining economic challenges of recent decades, weighing on income growth, public finances, and the country’s ability to deliver the infrastructure and housing it needs. Despite periods of reform and investment, productivity growth has steadily deteriorated relative to international peers, with insufficient capital deepening and innovation limiting gains in output per hour worked. Within this broader context, the construction sector has attracted particular scrutiny, reflecting both its importance to economic outcomes and the unique structural and cyclical pressures it faces.
This article looks at how construction fits within New Zealand’s wider productivity problem to help identify realistic pathways to stronger and more sustainable economic growth.
Productivity growth continues to wane
New Zealand’s long-standing productivity problem shows no signs of abating. The latest data from Stats NZ shows a continued deterioration in average labour productivity throughout the last four business cycles, stretching back to 1997 (see Chart 1). The most recent cycle, between 2020 and 2024, is probably not the most reliable indicator of underlying economic performance, given the severe disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic to normal economic conditions. However, taking data averaged over the last two business cycles, back to 2008, leads us to the same conclusion.
Data from the OECD in Chart 2 shows a significant weakening in the growth of capital services per hour worked, or capital deepening, between the Global Financial Crisis in 2008 and the pandemic in 2020. Simply put, we would generally expect increased capital investment and intensity over time to be associated with more output per hour worked. The economic reforms of the 1980s and spread of computing technology throughout much of the economy in the 1990s underpinned significant capital deepening, or growth in capital services per hour worked through until the late 2000s. But this growth dried up in the following decade, suggesting a lack of effective capital investment that has constrained New Zealand’s economic performance. By the second half of last decade, the government’s recipe for generating faster economic growth largely seemed to revolve around allowing more immigration and boosting GDP by sheer weight of numbers.
It's instructive that two of the better-performing industries during the 2008-2024 period, at least relative to their 1997-2008 outcomes, were retail trade along with accommodation and food services (see Chart 3). These two industries were ones where the incorporation of labour-saving technology has been slower than in many other parts of the economy. But growth in self-service checkouts, online shopping, and online booking platforms represents a tangible shift in the way that business is conducted and the reduced need for staff in key parts of the sales process.
Other OECD data shows how the deterioration in New Zealand’s productivity growth over the last 15-20 years has seen our economy fall further behind the rest of the developed world. Between 2012 and 2020, average OCED productivity lifted by 12.5%, while New Zealand’s productivity edged up by just 2.3%. Put another way, if New Zealand’s productivity had kept pace with the OCED over this eight-year period, our per-capita incomes would be 10% better than they are now.
Productivity challenges faced by construction
One industry that has at times attracted a large amount of attention for its productivity performance has been construction. Back in the early 2010s, a partnership between the government and industry aimed to lift construction’s productivity 20% by 2020. The goal was a stretch given that the industry’s last 20% lift in productivity had taken 14 years, and that 20% growth over the course of a 10-year period had only been measured once previously, between 1980 and 1990.
The end result for construction productivity between 2010 and 2020 was a modest 8.5% lift. Chart 5 shows how construction productivity has generally been left behind by economy-wide productivity measures over the last 40 years.
Even so, construction’s productivity performance is not quite as bad as it appears at first glance. Referring back to Chart 3, construction’s average productivity growth across the last four business cycles sits just below the middle of the pack on an industry-by-industry basis.
Extreme cyclicality a persistent problem
One of the factors often cited as holding construction back is the highly variable nature of activity over the course of the business cycle. This perception is confirmed by the data in Chart 6, which shows the variation between the peak and trough of activity across each of the last five business cycles, stretching back to 1990. On average, construction has the third-biggest swings from peak to trough, meaning the industry is often grappling with either too much work or not enough. That variability can place a lot of stress on firms in terms of cashflow, labour and capital resourcing, and medium-term business planning.
From a labour productivity point of view, the highly variable nature of work volumes can harm perceptions of job security and reduce the appeal of construction as a career choice, making it difficult to attract people into the industry if they can see better career options elsewhere. Even for workers within the industry, significant downturns in activity have the potential to force them out of the industry, with Australia proving to be a strong drawcard at times during previous cycles. Once those workers and their skills are lost across the Tasman, it is unlikely they will return to New Zealand, even when conditions improve here.
The highly cyclical nature of the industry can also reduce the appetite of firms to invest in capital, particularly where that capital has a long expected pay-off time, but there is little guarantee that demand will be strong enough in five years’ time to justify the investment. That reluctance to invest is likely to be even more acute around research and development (R&D), where the timeframes are typically even more extended and the returns less guaranteed. Yet the innovation and technological advancements associated with R&D are critical for improving labour productivity over the medium term. Add in the fact that financiers will probably be less willing to lend to firms in an industry where future returns are less certain, and it becomes even clearer that the environment for achieving sustained gains in productivity is a difficult one.
What hand is the government dealing to the industry?
The government can play a role in helping to reduce the variability and cyclicality of activity within the construction industry. There has been a lot of discussion in recent years about the need for broad agreement about a long-term infrastructure pipeline. Greater consensus would help provide more certainty for industry about future projects and their timing, rather than the stop-start nature of work that has been associated with changes of government over the last decade. The effects of greater policy consistency would be most obvious across civil and social infrastructure, but could also extend into the residential sector if there was broader agreement about appropriate levels of social housing provision.
Government procurement practices could also play a role in improving innovation and medium-term outcomes across the industry. Procurement is fundamentally about achieving value for money for projects, but the government arguably focuses too heavily on getting the lowest upfront cost without considering other objectives – especially when so often that lowest upfront cost turns out to be anything but low-cost in the long run. A more medium-term approach could involve placing some weighting on R&D or innovation in tenders, recognising that work might increase near-term costs to some degree, but could lead to improved outcomes in future projects. This implicit support for R&D could help the industry overcome some of the impediments to innovation and boost productivity over the medium term.
To some extent, government procurement also has a part to play in maintaining firm and industry work levels. In a small market like New Zealand with a limited number of businesses at scale, finding the balance between promoting competition in the short-term and ensuring that enough firms are sustained over the medium term is a difficult balancing act, particularly in the civil construction space. Apart from explicitly trying to spread projects around to some degree (while still rewarding the most efficient firms with more work), more appropriate risk-sharing models would ultimately improve the robustness of firms in the construction industry and could lead to lower overall costs over the medium-term.
The current government has also moved to reduce consenting delays and other regulatory impediments that have restricted productivity and contributed to higher costs in the construction industry. These changes have included publishing data on councils’ building consent processing times, introducing self-inspection for some building work and removing consent requirements for some other work, and altering building standards to broaden the materials and componentry that is allowed to be used within New Zealand. Many of these changes are largely focused around residential construction, with housing affordability still seen as a major problem for this country. If successful, other changes to zoning regulations and the Resource Management Act are likely to have a greater effect on housing affordability by improving the supply of land and bringing land prices down, but the regulatory changes noted above play an important role in making sure that government rules are not unduly adding to overall costs or stifling innovation.
Of SMEs, skills, and standardisation
The final pieces in construction’s productivity puzzle are the structure of the industry and the behaviour of firms themselves. In a nation of small and medium enterprises, construction is more dominated by small businesses than many other industries, with 70% of construction firms having five or fewer employees, compared to 60% of businesses across the entire economy.
That business profile feeds into a typical problem whereby firms do not have the ability (or appetite) to operate at scale, and they are often operated by people who have good technical or trades skills, but not necessarily good management or entrepreneurial skills. These issues can be overcome by investment in staff training to improve management capability. Investment in professional development can also ensure that firms and their workers are keeping up with technological changes and not continuing to do things “the way they’ve always been done”.
One example of this type of change is the increasing use of Building Information Modelling software that has enabled better integration of project management with technical skills, particularly ahead of the physical construction work getting underway. Resolving design clashes and inconsistencies virtually reduces the need for work to be redone onsite, avoiding delays that can be costly and can easily cascade into further delays and cost overruns in subsequent stages.
At a more macro level, greater standardisation of designs and products across the industry could enable more production at scale and a reduction in costs. The relatively small size of New Zealand’s construction market and our challenging geography suggest that complete offsite prefabrication of homes is unlikely to occur at any significant scale – particularly without the security of demand that some people hoped might have been provided by a large-scale government initiative such as the ill-fated KiwiBuild programme several years ago. But greater offsite manufacturing of items such as panels or kitchen and bathroom pods could improve efficiency and reduce waste, costs, and re-work. The prevalence of pre-nailed frames and trusses provides an example of offsite technology replacing onsite construction.
The surge in townhouse and terraced housing consents, from 6.5% of all new dwellings in 2013 to 45% by 2024, represents a significant step along the standardisation path. By their nature, these dwellings are likely to be more standardised and modular, with larger numbers effectively being built simultaneously on a single site. Of course, standalone houses are not immune to the standardisation process either, with new house building having become increasingly dominated by group home builders over the last few decades.
Productivity is critical to our living standards
The challenge of achieving better productivity growth is pivotal to New Zealand’s economic success over the medium term. Without a better productivity performance, our per-capita incomes will slip further behind the rest of the developed world, and we will not be able to sustain the living standards we expect.
The second half of this article has concentrated on areas where construction industry outcomes could be improved which, by extension, would boost our ability to address some of the large infrastructure deficit that has become more apparent over the last few years. However, we also note that improving productivity on an economy-wide basis is ultimately more important in addressing these poor infrastructure outcomes. Without GDP growth underpinned by productivity improvements, New Zealand will not be able to generate the income and associated tax revenue to pay for the standard of infrastructure we think we deserve.






